Maurice William's essays comparing concepts of evolution to those of creationism are directed to a younger audience (ages 9-12) than that which usually receives such considerations, and this offers the possibility of a dialogue between adults and teens over the topic, using Questioning Evolution's writings as a foundation for debate.
No matter what side the reader is on, it should be mentioned that the structure, contents, analysis and foundations of not just intelligent design but belief itself are analyzed using a blend of philosophical and spiritual inspection.
Despite Questioning Evolution's stated age range on Amazon, it should be mentioned that this is no light discussion, and doesn't adjust its tone or contents for a younger audience. From references to mutations and extinction-level events to how and why it is possible to misunderstand the physical origins of the universe itself, Williams applies physics and spirituality with an eye to exploring and explaining contrasting belief systems and approaches to both.
He
also succinctly outlines the differences between different, seemingly-opposite
perceptions and why it's important to consider them both as valid: "There
are two worlds I am immersed in: the physical world and the spiritual world. I
need to come to terms with both worlds. One can be investigated through
observation and experimentation; the other can only be approached through faith
in the testimony of someone who knows."
These introductory passages lay the groundwork for essays which range from a consideration of what is faulty about Darwinist thinking to human choices involved in going to Hell, the existence of extraterrestrial beings and their place in God's plan, a simpler perspective on what constitutes good and evil, and the hurdles of pride in a personal relationship with God.
Williams provides many thought-provoking insights that move from scientific discussion to an analysis of the mechanics of belief. Therefore, Questioning Evolution is a thought-provoking read best served up in religious settings not just to teens; but to a mixed group of adult and teen thinkers who will find in this collection a solid foundation for debates and personal analysis.
It cements its approach with author perspectives and insights to lend a personal touch needed not just for acceptance of its concepts, but how they can be digested and analyzed. The wide-reaching topics in these essays will surprise those who anticipated a survey centered on evolution; but the process is clearly more complex than a singular perspective about what constitutes evolution, embracing many different interpretations and approaches.
The
heart of the discussion lies in what can be accepted on faith alone. Adult and
teen audiences alike will find much to reflect upon, here.